The Great HP Debate #3: Flying Death Eaters (Spoilers Likely)

• Loretta Stone: sorry about the delayed reply but im done
  Mar 01, 10, 05:44:42 PM
• Azarius Scevola: I have replied, Lottie.
  Feb 19, 10, 01:21:46 AM
• Loretta Stone: me too!
  Feb 15, 10, 12:39:22 PM
• Straton Aalders: I've replied, Lottie
  Feb 14, 10, 06:46:10 PM
• Loretta Stone: i have just noticed the time and i have to bid you adue till its morning, so long
  Feb 10, 10, 06:04:21 PM
• Loretta Stone: im back
  Feb 10, 10, 06:03:13 PM
• James Oraval: Ok. Have a good evening / night ? I will probably asleeped when you come back ^^'
  Feb 10, 10, 05:52:04 PM
• Loretta Stone: ill be back in a moment
  Feb 10, 10, 05:48:34 PM
• Loretta Stone: ok
  Feb 10, 10, 05:48:05 PM
• James Oraval: I will read and probably post something.... I have just to find out what
  Feb 10, 10, 05:44:50 PM
• Loretta Stone: yeah
  Feb 10, 10, 05:27:50 PM
• James Oraval: Taking Over I suppose ^^'
  Feb 10, 10, 04:57:24 PM
• James Oraval: Taking over or Three boomstick ?
  Feb 10, 10, 04:55:28 PM
• Loretta Stone: its in hogsmeade
  Feb 10, 10, 04:51:22 PM
• James Oraval: Hi ^^
  Feb 10, 10, 04:35:11 PM
• James Oraval: Where is it ?
  Feb 10, 10, 04:35:06 PM
• Loretta Stone: hey james why don't you join our topic. We could do with some action like a fight or something
  Feb 10, 10, 04:27:43 PM
• Loretta Stone: me too now!
  Feb 10, 10, 02:43:59 AM
• Azarius Scevola: Finite!
  Feb 09, 10, 07:08:27 PM
• Loretta Stone: All done
  Feb 09, 10, 06:10:42 PM

• Guests: 7
• Hidden: 0
• Users: 0

There aren't any users online.

Important Links
Frequently Asked Questions
House/Group Sorting
Guide to SMF's Features

• Daniel - 13 Jun
• Arabella Adair - 15 May
• jonaslover6400 - 19 Apr
• Dream - 06 Mar
• EpicKnight - 04 Mar

56
25
20
05

• Who should Rowling not have killed off and why?
• Dumbledore
• 0 (0%)
• Fred
• 0 (0%)
• Tonks & Lupin
• 4 (100%)
• Someone else
• 0 (0%)
• I like them all dead!
• 0 (0%)
• Total Members Voted: 4
• View Topic

Username:
Password:
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

_{All information regarding Harry Potter are copyright JK Rowling. Everything else on the site, unless otherwise specified, whether graphics, ideas, or methodology, belongs to us.}

Some might consider us old-fashioned, but we want to return to when roleplay and community sites were fun and low stress. You are welcome to join just to be a part of the community, and not participate in the roleplay.  There is no posting limits on this site, either by word counts, or activity checks, or what have you. Applications to roleplay are not required. Our goal is to not take everything so seriously that nobody enjoys roleplaying anymore!

Some of our special features include a subaccount mod that allows you to make immediate alts and post to them from any account, dice-based OOC and IC Quidditch, custom BBCode-enabled profiles, a shop, unique graphic prizes, the ability to use both usernames and character names (at the same time!), custom house points, player graphic shops, member jobs to earn shop Galleons, and much more! You can read all about them in our
Guide to Special Features.
Oh, and this box disappears once you've joined!

Canon characters are available as alternate accounts only,
so please do not register with a canon character name or surname.

If you would like to learn more about us, please read our Frequently Asked Questions.

Give House Points:  

What do you think of this post?

I agree I disagree  
Comment:

[What did you think of the flying Death Eaters in OotP and HBP?]

What did you think of the flying Death Eaters in OotP and HBP?

It was totally wrong!

 3 (75%)

I just thought it was cool.

 0 (0%)

It was a bit off and would have been better without it.

 1 (25%)

Other

 0 (0%)

There is a plausible explanation.

 0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 4

[Roswenthe]

One thing I've heard mentioned a lot is the flying Death Eaters in the Half Blood Prince movie. It was actually done by both Death Eaters and the Order in Order of the Phoenix, but not quite to that extent.

What do you think?

[Quintessa Landley]

Stupid stupid stupid stupid!
I hated it! But I think from the movie rant, we already knew that. Lol.
In Order of the Pheonix, (the movie, not the group) I think they mainly used it in a sort of Apparating way, except that scene in the dias room, but then again, it was small distances.
Half Blood Prince just took it too far, having them flying all over london. *rolls eyes* So I take it no one is going to be surprised Voldemort can fly without a broom in the seventh film.

[Roswenthe]

I took it as the physical manifestation of apparating, but it still seemed a bit overboard.

[Kelly Quinn]

I enjoyed it but it confuses me. Wouldn't the muggles see them?

[Angus Mesmer]

I took it as the physical manifestation of apparating, but it still seemed a bit overboard.

It hardly looks instantaneous with the smoke trails.

[Astraea Raptis]

For some reason I can't vote in this poll, but I shall certainly add my opinion, though it's not a new one.

It's stupid. There's no need for it. Either give them brooms, or have them appear. Almost everyone watching the movie will know what Apparating is, so it makes way more sense than having them fly around!

That's the problem I have with book-based movies. So much of the time, they add or change things unnecessarily. How much would it have affected the movie plot or length if they'd just Apparated?

[Tags:]

Tags: potter books debate poll spoilers 

	Quiddtich practice [Quidditch Pitch]	Daniel Jun 13, 10, 03:43:15 PM
	World Cup Team Signups [World Cup Discussion]	Daniel Jun 13, 10, 03:37:47 PM
	Taking over... [Hogsmeade]	Loretta Stone Mar 01, 10, 05:44:20 PM
	Song Titles [Spam and Games]	Loretta Stone Feb 07, 10, 11:22:50 AM
	Potions Class [Open Join-All Levels] [Classes]	Loretta Stone Feb 06, 10, 12:44:33 PM

Read More | Write Comment

Read More | Write Comment

This text will be replaced by the flash music player.

Lotsa Topsites Role play Sites